Nothin’ Poor about the Poor Man’s Moorish Idol

A group of Schooling Bannerfish (Heniochus diphreutes) in a home aquarium

A group of Schooling Bannerfish (Heniochus diphreutes) in a home aquarium

Mother Nature must have a special place in her heart for marine aquarium hobbyists. It seems as though for every heartbreakingly challenging reef fish she created, she did us a solid by making a reasonable facsimile that is much hardier and better suited to aquarium life. Such is the case with the schooling bannerfish (Heniochus diphreutes) from the Indo-Pacific, which bears a striking resemblance to the coveted—but notoriously hard to keep—Moorish idol (Zanclus cornutus).

Though H. diphreutes is commonly dubbed the “poor man’s Moorish idol” or the “false Moorish idol,” these monikers do this species a great disservice in my opinion because they imply that it’s somehow a lesser species. After all, what’s “lesser” about a fish that’s almost certain to survive in your aquarium? (Maybe the Moorish idol should be called the “poor man’s schooling bannerfish”!)

Okay, maybe one could reasonably argue that it’s not quite as exotic-looking as Z. cornutus, particularly in the face (as a member of the family Chaetodontidae, H. diphreutes has a “typical” butterflyfish face), but the overall visual impression H. diphreutes creates in the aquarium—with its laterally compressed body; black, white, and yellow coloration; and long, trailing dorsal extension—is almost identical. Besides, H. diphreutes readily accepts standard aquarium fare and requires little coaxing to initiate feeding. Contrast that with Z. cornutas, which very commonly refuses food to the point of starvation in captivity.

Yes, you can keep a school

Fish that can actually be kept more than one to a tank are a rare commodity in the marine aquarium hobby, but H. diphreutes, as its common name suggests, is a noteworthy exception. If kept in a large enough tank (at least 125 gallons, with bigger being better) that offers plenty of open swimming space, multiple specimens can be kept together provided all are introduced simultaneously. I wouldn’t go any smaller than 100 gallons for a single specimen—this is an energetic species that can reach upwards of 8 inches.

Feeding is easy

schooling-bannerfish1As I mentioned, H. diphreutes presents little challenge when it comes to feeding. A planktivore by nature, it will snatch any small meaty foods drifting in the water column and will even accept dry pellets and flakes. Some greens, such as a commercial formulation for herbivores, should be included on the menu as well.

Peaceful tankmates, please!

Based on personal experience with this species, I can attest that it can be the target of harassment by more-aggressive species. I once introduced a specimen that was bullied relentlessly by a flame angelfish and pearlscale butterflyfish. The flame angel even went so far as to nip a chunk out of the bannerfish’s banner. I would limit tankmates to other relatively peaceful species, and as far as order of introduction is concerned, I’d add the banner(s) early on. I suspect my bullied bannerfish would have fared better in the same tank had it been introduced ahead of its tormentors.

Reef safety

I’ve never kept H. diphreutes in a reef tank, but it’s known to be inoffensive toward sessile invertebrates. However, do be aware that other Heniochus spp. are sometimes available in the hobby, some of which are more or less reef-safe than others.

For example, the almost-identical-looking longfin bannerfish (H. acuminatus) is reputed to be a threat to sessile invertebrates. To tell these two species apart, look closely at the anal fin. On H. diphreutes, the posterior vertical black band extends all the way to the point of the anal fin, while on H. acuminatus, the black band terminates above the point of the fin. Supposedly there are also differences in the snout length and the fullness of the two species’ chests, but unless you have both species side by side for comparison, these aren’t necessarily the best distinguishing characteristics to look for. If you plan to buy banners for a reef tank and have any doubt about their identity, be sure to verify the species with your dealer.

Photo credit: Moto@Club4AG, Justin Morgan

Related posts:

SUBSCRIBE TO THE “SALT SMART” NEWSLETTER

If you enjoyed this post, subscribe to get our new posts in your email.
About Jeff Kurtz

Jeff Kurtz is the Co-founder/Editor of Saltwater Smarts, former Senior Consulting Editor for Tropical Fish Hobbyist Magazine, and the aquarist formerly known as “The Salt Creep.” He has been an aquarium hobbyist for over 30 years and is an avid scuba diver.

Comments

  1. Paul Baldassano says:

    The Bannerfish comes from the exact same reefs as the (in my opinion) better looking Moorish Idol, as while I was studying Moorish Idols in Tahiti I ran into plenty of bannerfish.
    They live in schools and I saw most f them in shallow water, but that doesn’t mean they also don’t go deep. They are peaceful and are certainly easier to keep than Idols which I only saw eating lime green sponges.
    I took this picture of a Moorish Idol in Bora Bora who was swimming a few yards from bannerfish.
    I am not sure if the picture will post.

    http://s258.photobucket.com/user/urchsearch/media/tahiti.jpg.html
    http://i258.photobucket.com/albums/hh270/urchsearch/tahiti.jpg

  2. Matt Bowers (Muttley000) says:

    A species I had never considered, but a school in a large tank gets the wheels turning!

    • Chris Aldrich says:

      Agreed, Matt! The thought of a nice-sized school of H. diphreutes in a 300-400 gallon reef delights my fish geek tendencies.

Speak Your Mind

*